First Circuit Clarifies that Song Royalties Belong to Artists

First Circuit Clarifies that Song Royalties Belong to Artists

 

On June 18, 2024, the First Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that members of musical groups, rather than their owners or managers, are entitled to featured “recording artists” royalties under federal law. This decision overturned a previous ruling that had assigned royalty payments to the founder of El Gran Combo, a renowned Puerto Rican salsa band, instead of the group’s longtime singer, Carlos Juna Aponte-Cruz.

The opinion, penned by Chief Judge David J. Barron, determined that Aponte-Cruz was entitled to a 45% royalty as a “featured” recording artist, as established by Congress in the 1995 Digital Performance Right in Sound Recordings Act. Judge Barron drew an analogy to the Beatles to support his reasoning. “If you think that Paul, John, George and Ringo were ‘the recording artist[s] … featured’ on the ‘White Album’ — even though that iconic record’s cover mentioned none of The Beatles by name — then you will not be surprised by the analysis that follows,” he wrote.

Judge Barron dismissed arguments that had been upheld by a federal judge in Puerto Rico, who had decided that El Gran Combo’s royalties should be distributed to the band and its founder, Rafael Ithier, the owner of the group. Ithier contended that the term “featured,” as defined by the statute, would exclude band members not named on an album cover. Since the recordings only included the band’s name and not individual members, Ithier argued that the group as a whole should be considered the featured artist. Judge Barron disagreed, stating that the lower court’s decision lacked foundation in the federal statute’s wording, congressional intent, and common sense.

The statute states that a featured artist is “an artist who performs on a sound recording.” The First Circuit concluded that the word “who” in this context refers to a natural person, not an artificial entity like Ithier’s company. An amicus brief from SoundExchange, a royalty distributor, supported this interpretation, arguing that the lower court’s holding was a significant deviation from the text and history of the Copyright Act.

The First Circuit further determined that individual band members are featured artists, while session musicians, backup vocalists, and chorus members are nonfeatured artists. The court affirmed that, in accordance with the statute, royalties are primarily allocated to featured artists, with a much smaller share going to non-featured artists. Judge Barron used the White Album to illustrate his point: Frederick Alexander, the cello player on “Martha My Dear,” is a nonfeatured artist, whereas John Lennon and Paul McCartney were found to be “featured” artists.

Jose A. Hernandez Mayoral, attorney for Aponte-Cruz, hailed the ruling as a pivotal decision for musicians who were previously unaware of their rights to royalties. He emphasized that the clarity of the statutory language, congressional record, and industry practice made the lack of case law irrelevant in this instance.

Ithier and EGC Corp. are represented by Roberto Sueiro Del Valle.

Aponte-Cruz is represented by José A. Hernández Mayoral.

The case is Ithier et al. v. Aponte-Cruz, case number 22-1859, in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit.

* Lowe & Associates (“The Firm”) is a boutique entertainment and business law firm located in Beverly Hills, California. The firm has extensive experience handling cases involving copyright law, having provided top-quality legal services to its clients since 1991. The Firm is recognized for its many achievements, including successfully litigating many high-profile cases.

You may also like…

How to Protect Your Script From Being Stolen

How to Protect Your Script From Being Stolen

The only surefire way to protect your screenplay from being stolen is not to let anybody read it. Unfortunately, that also means it has zero chance of ever being “greenlit.” Therefore, it becomes a matter of probabilities, meaning there is no surefire way to avoid the possibility of theft entirely, but there are ways to increase the probability that it will not get stolen (or if it does, that you will be able to find a lawyer to take your case).

Defend Your Creative Legacy

In the realm of entertainment, your creative property isn’t just a product, it’s a piece of your soul, a testament to your passion, dedication, and vision.

At Lowe & Associates, we understand that, and we’re here to fiercely protect what’s rightfully yours. If you find yourself needing to defend your intellectual property, don’t stand alone. Team up with experts who have consistently showcased their ability to champion creative rights against all odds.

Are you ready to fight for your creative property?

Reach out to us today and let’s ensure your legacy remains untarnished.